Six First Nations that have filed another legal challenge against the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion say Canada’s ownership of the corporation behind the project created a bias that prevented full consultations as ordered by the Federal Court of Appeal.
Chief Leah George-Wilson of the Tsleil-Waututh Nation said Canada had an opportunity to “get it right,” but failed to take environmental risks into consideration as part of a rushed consultation process.
“It does feel like deja vu,’’ George-Wilson said, reflecting on the first court challenge 2.5 years ago that resulted in a ruling requiring the federal government to redo consultations.
The Federal Court of Appeal shelved the original approval last summer and the federal government approved the pipeline expansion again last month after a second round of consultations with First Nations.
“We have not seen any significant difference in the consultation process and, in some ways, it was worse,” George-Wilson said.
She said she expects the latest approval will be overturned based on the same mistakes the federal government made the first time with its failure to conduct meaningful consultations.
In August 2018, the federal government purchased the pipeline and expansion project for $4.5 billion, saying it was in the national interest to build the country’s energy infrastructure and to preserve jobs.
However, George-Wilson said Canada was unresponsive to oil spill risks to whales and climate change.
“Canada withheld information regarding their scientific assessments of diluted bitumen impacts and only provided this information to Tseil Watuth after the formal close of consultation,’’ she said.
Skeetchestn Indian Band Chief Ron Ignace said the second round of “harried’’ consultations did not provide the opportunity to respond to complex questions.
“I would like to say to the ordinary people across Canada: Our fight is not with you, our fight is with your government, with the leaders that are making these kinds of decisions.
“However, you have a duty and a responsibility to see that your governments do the right thing by us, and that’s for both provincial and federal governments.’’
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said after announcing the second approval of the pipeline that Natural Resources Minister Amarjeet Sohi held meetings and met with Indigenous groups as part of the process.
Sohi has said Ottawa can demonstrate that is has listened to the concerns of Indigenous communities and responded to them.
Vanessa Adams, Sohi’s press secretary, said the government cannot comment on the legal action because it is before the courts.
But she said in an email the government is confident it followed the guidance of the Federal Court of Appeal and “fulfilled our duty to consult with Indigenous communities by engaging in meaningful, two-way dialogue.’’